Welcome to E.J. Dwyer Co.   

    Representing Quality Manufacturers with Our Service Excellence!

         

 

Emergency Eye Wash and Shower Equipment - Revised January 2004 ANSI Z358.1 Standard

        The ANSI Z358.1 standard has been revised. The new standard took effect in January and is marked as the 2004 version. It is available for purchase from the International Safety Equipment Association www.safetyequipment.org at a purchase price of $53.00 per copy. Since this is a copy written document, we can not provide photocopies of the standard. The new 2004 standard has changed little from the 1998 version.

 

Some of the changes to highlight include:

 

  • Section 4.4.1(2) – Drench showers must now be connected to a flushing fluid supply that provides a minimum 20GPM at 30 PSI. The “30 PSI” was not specified in the 1998 standard for drench showers.

 

  • Section 5.5.2, 6.5.2, and 7.5.2 – The addition of a note stating the intent of the weekly activation of plumbed eyewash and eye/face wash units. The standard note states that the weekly activation is to clear the supply line of sediment build-up and minimize microbial contamination. Bradley does not install in-line strainers into our emergency eyewash units for this exact reason.

 

  • Section 8.2.1 – Addition of a note stating that a drench hose can be considered an eye/face wash if it meets the entire performance criteria of an eye/face wash. Some of these criteria are proper mounting height, stay open activation, dual head for spray pattern, ability to use both hands to hold eyes open, proper flow rate, and clear path of travel within 10 seconds. Bradley has several models that will now comply when the criteria are met. Two examples are the S19-460EFW and the S19-630. The S19-460EFW includes a locking clip on the handle to provide the “stay open” capability. The S19-630 include the stay open push handle available on our standard wall mounted eye/face wash units.

 

  • Tepid Water – Is defined as moderately warm, lukewarm. No specific temperature range is provided in the standard. However, Appendix B6 provides additional detail. The appendix states temperatures over 100 degrees Fahrenheit can be harmful to the eyes, and 60 degrees Fahrenheit is suitable as a lower parameter. The standard still indicates that in circumstances where chemical reaction is accelerated by flushing fluid temperature, a safety/health advisor should be consulted for the optimum temperature for each application. Please see Powers or Bradley for mixing valve information.

 

  • Barrier Free/ADA Compliant Fixtures – The ANSI Z358.1 standard provides no information for disabled use. In addition, there is no specific information in the ADA standards relating to Emergency Fixtures. Bradley and other manufacturers use the ANSI A117.1 and ADA standards for similar fixtures to determine appropriate knee clearance, wall distances, pull forces, etc for our Barrier Free Fixtures. No manufacturer should claim their product is ADA Compliant. Please visit ADA Compliance  for complete ADA information and guidelines.

 

Emergency Eye Wash and Shower Equipment - ANSI Z358.1   1998 Standard

 

American National Standards Institute (ANSI) has adopted ANSI Standard Z358.1 that details more specific requirements for emergency equipment that are commonly used by OSHA during a facility inspection. Although ANSI Z358.1 is a voluntary standard, OSHA can and typically does use ANSI criteria when issuing a citation or violation in the workplace if eye wash and shower equipment does not conform to the standard.

Regulatory Requirements Background:

29 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations) 1910.151 essentially states "where the eyes or body of any person may be exposed to injurious corrosive materials, suitable facilities for quick drenching or flushing of the eyes and body shall be provided within the work area for immediate emergency use".

OSHA inspections can be scheduled on a regular basis, occur randomly without prior notice or may occur due to a complaint as a result of an accident within the workplace. If a violation is found during an OSHA inspection, the consequence may range from a warning, monetary fine or even a plant shut-down.

On April 16, 1998, the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) approved a series of proposed changes to the Z358.1-1990 Standard. These changes are intended to enhance minimum performance and use requirements for eye wash and shower equipment in order to maximize worker protection in the workplace. The updated standard that is now in effect is ANSI Z358.1-1998.

 

The following changes outlined below are specific to the sections of the standard that have changed from the previous standard.

ANSI Z358.1 Standard - Emergency Eye Wash and Shower Equipment


WATER FLOW (sections 4.1, 4.5.1, 4.5.2)  Please see top of page for 2004 Revision!

  • Old: Emergency Shower Heads should be capable of delivering a minimum of 113.6 liters per minute (30 gallons per minute) of water.....
  • New 1998 Standard: Emergency Shower Heads shall be capable of delivering a minimum of 75.7 liters per minute (20 gallons per minute) of flushing fluid.....

Comments: Most emergency drench showers flow between 45-60 gpm when in use. The amount of water discharged during the 15 minute use requirement specified by ANSI at this flow rate is considerable (900 gallons). In an effort to better manage the disposal of flushing fluid released in an emergency drench shower application, the minimum flow rate was revised from 30 gpm to 20 gpm or minimum of 300 gallons of waste. Because many drench showers are manufactured to exceed the 20 gpm minimum at 45-60 gpm, a 20 or 30 GPM Flow Control can be added to the drench shower equipment to minimize the amount of waste discharged. Commonly, flow controls can be purchased as a separate retrofit part through the manufacturer or distributor. Always check with the manufacturer before purchasing and installing this type of equipment to have an understanding of the flow rate specified for this piece of equipment so you can accommodate for drainage accordingly. Please note: drainage is not specifically addressed in the ANSI Standard. Proper disposal of waste while using eye wash and shower equipment should be handled in accordance with local and state authorities.


Plumbed and Self Contained Emergency Showers (section 4.1)

  • Old: not applicable
  • New 1998 Standard: The eye wash section of a combination shower/eyewash station is not considered an "obstruction" in this context to allow for simultaneous use of shower and eye wash equipment.

Comments: This verbiage was added for clarification purposes under plumbed and self-contained emergency showers to include combination showers. The original statement in the old standard indicates that the center of the spray pattern for a drench shower shall be located at least 40.6 cm (16 in.) from any obstruction. The new language in the revised standard simply verifies that the addition of an eye wash in this case is not considered an obstruction when the shower is in use.


DISTANCE of Emergency Eye Wash and Shower Equipment From Potential Hazard (sections 4.6.1, 5.4.4, 7.4.4, 9.4.1)

  • Old: Emergency drench showers and combination drench showers, eye and eye/face washes, shall be in accessible locations that require no more than 10 seconds to reach and should be within a travel distance no greater than 30.5 meters (100 feet) from the hazard.
  • New: Emergency drench showers and combination drench showers, eye and eye/face washes, shall be in accessible locations that require no more than 10 seconds to reach. The showers and eye/face washes shall be located on the same level as the hazard and the path of travel shall be free of obstructions that may inhibit the immediate use of the equipment. (4.6.1) Where the possibility of freezing conditions exists, equipment shall be protected from freezing or freeze protected equipment shall be installed. (5.4.4). For a strong acid or strong caustic, the eye wash should be immediately adjacent to the hazard. It is recommended that the consulting physician or appropriate professional be contacted for advice on the proper distance.

Comments: The travel distance (30.5 meters or 100 feet) from the hazard was removed from the revised standard and 10 seconds was retained as a general guideline for equipment location. It is recommended that a hazard assessment be conducted at each workstation or job-site to determine what hazards are present (i.e. highly caustic) and rate of absorption into the skin. This information will help determine location of the equipment using the guidelines established by ANSI. As a general rule of thumb, the average person walks at a rate of 4 miles per hour so therefore a 10 second walking distance from a potential hazard would equate to approximately 50-100 feet. Per ANSI, it is highly advised that in any case, a consulting physician or appropriate professional be contacted for advice on the proper distance especially where the potential for injury is rated high.


SIGNS/LIGHTING (sections 4.6.2, 5.4.5, 7.4.5, 8.4.3, 9.4.2)

  • Old: Each Emergency Fixture location shall be identified with a highly visible sign. The area around the emergency shower shall be well lighted and highly visible.
  • New 1998 Standard: Each Emergency Fixture location shall be identified with a highly visible sign positioned so the sign shall be visible within the area served by the equipment. The area around the equipment shall be well lighted.

Comments: In many cases, signage for eye wash and shower equipment is not properly positioned so as a person with impaired vision can easily identify where the equipment is located. When installing eye wash and shower equipment it is critical that the signage be placed either on the equipment at eye level or within several feet of the equipment at eye level. The area around the equipment should also be lighted so all operating parts of the equipment can be easily identified. In addition to proper signage and lighting, all employees should be properly trained not only as to the location of the equipment, but how to properly operate the equipment as well. A written emergency response plan outlines specific procedures to be used in an emergency situation is also highly recommended.


SHUT-OFF VALVE (addition to the revised standard, sections 4.6.4, 5.1.5, 7.1.4)

  • Old: not applicable
  • New 1998 Standard: If shut off valves are installed in the shower line for maintenance purposes, provisions shall be made to prevent unauthorized shut off.

Comments: Shut-off valves are not standard equipment to emergency eye washes and showers. Typically shut-off valves are installed on the main water supply line running to the eye wash or shower equipment for maintenance purposes. In any event, it is the responsibility of the facility owner or operator to designate a person or persons to maintain the equipment. This person should be given sole authority and responsibility to ensure shut-off valves are in the open position and locked at all times when the equipment is not being maintained.


WATER TEMPERATURE (addition to the revised standard, sections 4.6.6, 5.4.6, 6.2.5, 7.4.6, 8.4.4, 9.4.5)    Please see top of page for 2004 Revision!

  • Old: water temperature was addressed only in the appendix of the standard, which is not considered part of the standard itself, but for information only.
  • New 1998 Standard: Delivered flushing fluid temperature shall be tepid. In circumstances where chemical reaction is accelerated by flushing fluid temperature, a medical advisor should be consulted for the optimum temperature for each application. Tepid is defined in the revised standard as "Moderately Warm, Lukewarm". Additional information regarding delivered flushing fluid temperature is also included in Appendix B of the revised standard.

Comments: ANSI specifies a full 15 minute drench application to eyes, face and/or body during eye wash and shower equipment use. To encourage the full 15 minute flushing period, it is recommended that a comfortable water temperature be provided for this purpose. In many cases, a single "cold" water supply is used with this type of equipment, which if not properly tempered could result in hypothermic shock or accelerated absorption of chemicals into the skin. Although a comfortable temperature range is considered at 65-90 degrees farenheight, a medical consultant should be used to determine optimum temperature range for each application. Water temperature can be regulated by the use of Thermostatic Mixing Valves that require an incoming hot and cold water supply line to the valve. The valve blends both hot and cold water to a set temperature point and the output water to the eye wash and shower equipment is in essence tempered water. Other types of water tempering devices can be used but it is advised to consult with a plumbing engineer as to the best application for your facility. Please note, any water tempering devices selected for use with eye wash and shower equipment should have a positive hot water shut-off in the event the cold water supply fails to eliminate any risk of scalding. A cold-water by-pass should also be standard to the valve to ensure water availability in the event that the hot water supply fails.


MAINTENANCE AND TRAINING (addition to the revised standard, sections 4.7.1, 5.5.1, 6.2.1, 7.5.1, 8.5.1, 9.5.1)

  • Old: not applicable
  • New 1998 Standard: Manufacturers shall provide operation, inspection and maintenance instructions with shower and eye wash equipment. Instructions for all emergency equipment shall be readily accessible to maintenance and training personnel.

Comments: All documentation for emergency eye wash and shower equipment should be filed in a designated area next to the equipment. It is recommended that equipment be tested weekly to ensure proper operation. Testing of equipment should be documented on an inspection tag, which can be filed with the instruction manual or tagged to the equipment itself.


ANNUAL EQUIPMENT INSPECTIONS (4.7.4, 5.5.4, 7.5.4, 8.5.4, 9.5.4)

  • Old: not applicable
  • New 1998 Standard: All emergency equipment shall be inspected annually to assure conformance with ANSI Z358.1 section requirements.

Comments: This verbiage was added with the intention of ensuring equipment is tested at least once a year by equipment owners per ANSI specifications. In addition to annual testing, plumbed eye washes and drench showers should be tested weekly not only to ensure proper operation as noted above, but to clean the water supply line from iron and other water deposits that build-up if the water remains stagnant for too long. Flushing the water of impurities reduces the risk of further infection while drenching and helps maintain the integrity of the equipment. Portable (self-contained) eye wash equipment should be maintained in accordance with manufacturer instructions. In most cases, self-contained eye washes use potable water with a water preservative. Most additives will only protect bacteria, algae and fungi growth in the eye wash tank for up to 6 months.


EYE WASH TESTING (new addition to the proposed standard, section 5.1.7)

  • Old: not applicable
  • New 1998 Standard: The eye wash unit shall provide flushing fluid to both eyes simultaneously. A test gauge for making determination of a suitable eye wash pattern shall be a minimum 10.16 cm (4 in.) in length with two sets of parallel lines equidistant from the center. The interior set of lines shall be 3.18 cm (1.25 in.) apart and the exterior lines shall be 8.26 cm (3.25 in.) apart. Place the gauge on top of the stream of the eye wash. The flushing fluid should cover the areas between the interior and exterior lines when the gauge is lowered not more than 3.81 cm (1.5 in.) below the fluids peak. For reference, see Illustration 3c Typical Eye Wash Gauge, page 21 Z358.1-1998 Standard.

Comments: A eye wash test gauge can be obtained through the manufacturer or distributor of eye wash and shower equipment products. The gauge is a very helpful tool to use while testing eye wash equipment to ensure the spray pattern conforms to ANSI standards. Eye wash spray patterns that do not conform should be repaired or replaced immediately. Common causes for an irregular spray pattern include lime or mineral deposit build-up in the eye wash sprayhead and/or yoke assembly. In this case, the yoke assembly should be cleaned out by using a flexible scrub brush to remove any debris. If the yoke assembly is permanently obstructed with debris that can’t be removed, a new yoke assembly should be installed. Other causes for an irregular spray pattern may include the omission of a flow control device in the spray head or yoke assembly or the flow control may be malfunctioning. In the event that the spray pattern is irregular, the manufacturer of the equipment should be contacted for instruction.


MANUFACTURER PERFORMANCE TESTING (sections 5.3.1, 5.3.2, 7.3, 9.3)

  • Old: The manufacturer shall test emergency equipment........
  • New 1998 Standard: The manufacturer shall certify emergency equipment........

Comments: Certify is defined in the revised standard as "to test by a third-party to verify performance requirements as specified in this standard". This requirement puts onerous on the manufacturer of eye wash and shower equipment to implement a more standardized quality assurance program with their products to guarantee compliance with ANSI regulatory requirements. This guarantee ensures all users of the equipment that it will work properly in the event of an emergency. When purchasing eye wash and shower equipment, make sure it is certified through an outside testing agency (a certified agency other than the manufacturer). Most recognized third party certification organizations of eye wash and shower equipment include SEI (Safety Equipment Institute) and CSA (Canadian Standards Association).


COMBINATION SHOWERS WITH EYE AND EYE/FACE WASHES (section 9.4.4)

  • Old: The unit shall be connected to a system capable of supplying adequate flushing fluid to meet the requirements of each component as outlined in section 4,5,7 and 8. It is not necessary for all components to operate simultaneously (individual conditions will dictate this requirement).
  • New 1998 Standard: The unit shall be connected to a system capable of supplying adequate flushing fluid to meet the requirements of each component as outlined in sections 4,5,7 and 8 when all components are operated simultaneously. Combination unit components shall be capable of operating simultaneously and shall be positioned so that components may be used simultaneously by the same user.

Comments: This specification requires that when a combination drench shower with eye wash is being used, all components must be able to operate at the same time and still meet minimum flow rate requirements. Per ANSI the following minimum flow rates at 30 PSI apply:

Eye Wash:

.4 GPM

Face Wash:

3 GPM

Drench Hose:

3 GPM

Drench Shower:

20 GPM

In addition, all parts of the drench shower and eye wash should be positioned so they can be used at the same time.

 

Home

 

Copyright 2008